This website uses cookies for anonymised analytics and for account authentication. See our privacy and cookies policies for more information.





The voice of Scotland’s vibrant voluntary sector

Published by Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations

TFN is published by the Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations, Caledonian Exchange, 19A Canning Street, Edinburgh EH3 8EG. The Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations (SCVO) is a Scottish Charitable Incorporated Organisation. Registration number SC003558.

EXCLUSIVE: MND Scotland at ‘risk of closure’ as staff face redundancy and salary cuts

 

The charity’s CEO left last week, with the board's chair also exiting

A Scottish health charity is in crisis after it was revealed its leadership is leaving, salaries are being cut for all staff, and voluntary redundancies are open to all. 

TFN has been made aware of a number of issues facing MND Scotland, including its CEO leaving last week, and the charity’s chair stepping down - neither of which have been reported publicly. 

All staff have also been asked to take voluntary redundancy, TFN understands, with the announcement made on Thursday, 2 October. 

Staff who remain will have their salaries reduced to 80% of their current levels, with vital services - including advocacy work - having already been cut in recent months. 

One staff member told TFN: “This is not because of the funding crisis many Scottish charities are facing, rather a complete failure of leadership and governance over the last four years.

“A new chair and CEO were installed in 2021, and there has been a catalogue of governance failure since.

“There is a real risk that MND Scotland could close, similar to Cancer Support Scotland recently. This will be devastating to the people who need support.”

Since 2021 MND Scotland has run significant deficits, according to official accounts filed with charity regulator OSCR. 

In 2021, a deficit of £188,144 was reported, jumping to £781,402 in 2022. 

The amount lost in one year had risen again to £1,245,943 in 2023, and £1,368,251 in 2024. 

In total, MND Scotland spent £3,583,740 more since 2021 than it had brought in. 

Now ex-CEO Rachel Maitland joined MND Scotland in 2021, while the most recent chair listed on the charity’s accounts is Adrian Murphy - who has also left the organisation. 

In their 2024 submission of accounts, the charity’s trustees wrote in a section titled “risk management” that “the Trustees are satisfied that systems are in place to mitigate exposure to the major risks and have a risk management strategy that involves reviewing the financial, operational and management performance of the charity annually”. 

The report added that “there was an expected deficit in the year (2024)”. However, reserves had dropped to £1,441,498 by March 2024, down from £2,831,146, a year earlier. 

Dr Jane Haley, MND Scotland’s director of research, has been appointed interim CEO of the charity. 

She will report to the board of trustees, interim co-chaired by Liz McRobb from Shepherd and Wedderburn and Callum Paterson from the University of Edinburgh.

Over the past decade or so, MND Scotland has risen to become one of the country's best known charities, and it was associated with 2014's ice bucket challenge fundraising craze.

A spokesperson for the charity told TFN: “Like many charities, we are navigating an extremely challenging financial environment and it has become clear that immediate action is required to ensure the long-term stability of the charity. The wellbeing of our colleagues is our absolute priority and we shared the position with colleagues as soon as we were aware. We are now working closely with colleagues on a range of potential options.”  

 

Comments

0 0
Sarah
18 days ago
Rachel maitland name is very easy to Google and she deserves to be held accountable. This is not sloppy journalism. Holiday lodges are not more important than the vital services MND Scotland provided, which may not be able to happen now.
0 0
John
17 days ago

@Eleanor. Today's email from the interim CEO clearly blames the previous CEO and Chair for the current catastrophic situation. "We are sorry that we have been put in this position, and we share your disappointment and your frustration." If this was 'planned expenditure' it was without proper oversight and reasonable financial control. This is a basic responsibility of the Trustees, and it's quite astonishing that some of those responsible remain in post.

0 0
Boaby
18 days ago

Holiday accommodation? What did they build for £5m?

0 0
Caroline
17 days ago
Sadly the charity has gone downhill since they replaced well experienced fund raisers and their wellness coordinator in 2021/2. They took on many new staff , paying high wages- The CEO and managers being paid salarys of £50/60/70 thousand pa .A CEO of a charity being paid almost double the wages of a specialised nurse! The grants that had been available previously for wellness for those living with this awful disease was greatly reduced and then means tested. As soon as I heard Adrian was no longer on the board I knew Rachel Maitland would leave- a prediction made years ago by MND supporters. It's a sad day to hear that this charity is sinking- many people including myself had supported it for many years. The ones who truly suffer are those living with this disease and their families. Hopefully someone will come in and turn it around and make this charity great again!
0 0
Graham
17 days ago

My wife passed away in Mar 24 due to MND. The NHS support nurse was fantastic and supported both myself and wife to the hilt. She even came to my wife's funeral. I sincerely hope that this crisis can be turned around.

0 0
Eleanor
19 days ago

What sloppy journalism. There is no context as to what the deficit was spent and no mention that this was planned expenditure. MND Scotland were sitting on £5m unspent money. It was a failure of previous leadership and governance to NOT spent donors money. Did you look back at anual reports from before 2021? Did you see that among other things that donor money was spent on holiday accommodation for people with MND, did you look and see how that was of great benefit to the families of people living with MND. No you just grabbed a headline, named people and put them at risk of abuse. Shame on you.