This website uses cookies for anonymised analytics and for core features such as voting on polls and comments. See our privacy and cookies policies for more information.

The voice of Scotland’s vibrant voluntary sector

Published by Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations

TFN is published by the Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations, Mansfield Traquair Centre, 15 Mansfield Place, Edinburgh, EH3 6BB. The Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations (SCVO) is a Scottish Charitable Incorporated Organisation. Registration number SC003558.

Secret papers show DWP knew benefit cuts would hit vulnerable hardest

This news post is about 6 years old

Government ministers knew back-to-work tests were hitting vulnerable hardest but took no action despite warnings.

Secret internal inquiries into the deaths of people claiming benefits reveal government ministers were warned that vulnerable claimants would suffer most.

The information is revealed in 49 Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) inquiry reports, known as peer reviews, released to campaigners after the government finally gave in to Freedom of Information (FOI) requests.

The reviews were mostly undertaken after claimant suicides and though they do not make a direct link between benefit cuts and claimant deaths, they highlight widespread flaws that lead to vulnerable claimants experiencing trauma.

They show the DWP often failed to deal appropriately with vulnerable clients.

One report suggests that while official written policy demanded vulnerable claimants to be treated appropriately this was not implemented in practice. It says: “This case may highlight a dislocation between policy intent and what actually happens to claimants who are vulnerable.”

They have been playing Russian roulette with people’s lives and these peer reviews show that they have known this all the time - John McArdle

Another said that vulnerable claimants risked being overlooked by DWP officials, with potentially harmful consequences, because staff resources were stretched by a ministerial decision to push ahead with the speedy re-assessment of hundreds of thousands of incapacity benefit claimants.

It says: “We need to ask whether or not in the context of a fast-moving environment of high [claimant re-assessment] volumes and anticipated levels of performance, the current process requires, encourages and supports ... colleagues to independently and systematically consider claimant vulnerability.”

Work Capability Assessments (WCA), the test used to assess whether claimants are fit for work, have been at the centre of the problems. Campaigners argue the tests are flawed causing undue stress and exacerbating illness.

WCAs have since been linked to a number of deaths including poet Paul Reekie, former sheep farmer Nick Barker and ex-security guard Brian McArdle – all of whom died after being found “fit for work”.

Ministers initially denied back in 2014 that they held any records on people whose deaths may have been linked to benefits system.

However campaigners have pushed for the release of the documents and have now just received them.

John McArdle, co-founder of campaign group Black Triangle, said: “They have been playing Russian roulette with people’s lives and these peer reviews show that they have known this all the time.”

A DWP spokesman said it would be wrong to link benefit claims with deaths. “Any suicide is a tragedy and the reasons for them are complex, however it would be inaccurate and misleading to link it solely to a person’s benefit claim.”



0 0
Lawrence bancroft
about 6 years ago
All this evidence points to a policy of wickidness and hate of the sick and disabled
0 0
Halima Brewer
about 6 years ago
See the Ken Loach film "I Daniel Blake" which tackles this issue.
0 0
norah kennedy
about 6 years ago
it is so bad what they are putting people through no wounder people take there own lives
0 0
James J Daly
about 6 years ago
MP's are not the people to decide the benefits people are entitled to this should be a mixture of doctors and members of the public and there should be no interference from MP s
0 0
Naomi Dure
about 6 years ago
It is well known, surely ? that stress exacerbates any illness, claiming benefits is incredibly stressful, especially with all the additional complications caused by them changing the rules, changing the way you claim, what you may or may not be entitled to etc. Then you also have the added stigma from society and the media for being a benefits claimant. So it does not surprise me in any way that people cannot cope and when all avenues they see open to them closing in front their eyes, even an appt. at the GP taking 3 weeks and then when you get to see GP if you are lucky enough for them to even count you as a person with a real problem and they refer you for psychiatric help you will then have a further wait of 3 plus weeks before even getting an appt. That appt. can then be another 3 weeks away and that's only for an assessment. Trying to cope and sort all this when you are struggling mentally is hard enough, for some impossible.. but add in a physical health issue as well and add no money and piles of unpaid bills due to all the benefit cuts and it is no surprise people choose to take their own lives. SO government.. do not tell me the benefit cuts and changes are not responsible for the increase in benefit claiming suicides.. You are lying.