This website uses cookies for anonymised analytics and for account authentication. See our privacy and cookies policies for more information.





The voice of Scotland’s vibrant voluntary sector

Published by Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations

TFN is published by the Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations, Mansfield Traquair Centre, 15 Mansfield Place, Edinburgh, EH3 6BB. The Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations (SCVO) is a Scottish Charitable Incorporated Organisation. Registration number SC003558.

Police asked to investigate former DWP ministers

This news post is over 8 years old
 

​Campaigner believes former ministers should be held personally responsible for death of claimant

A prominent disability activists has complained to Police Scotland over the actions of former work and pensions secretary Iain Duncan Smith and former employment minister Chris Grayling.

John McArdle, co-founder of disability campaign group Black Triangle, has lodged a complaint with police in Edinburgh saying the two Conservative politicians are guilty of the Scottish criminal offence of wilful neglect of duty by a public official.

He claims they failed to take steps to improve the work capability assessment (WCA) in 2010 after being warned by a coroner that its flaws risked causing future deaths.

Police Scotland confirmed a complaint had been made.

A spokeswoman said: “Police in Edinburgh received a report of misconduct in public office on 23 March 2016.

“The individual who made the complaint has been spoken to and we are awaiting further information to assess this matter and establish what actions are required.”

McArdle’s complaint centres on the suicide of Stephen Carré in January 2010.

Carré took his own life in 2010 after he lost an appeal against the finding that he was fit to return to work. He was clinically depressed and had been diagnosed as bipolar.

At the inquest into his death the coroner ruled that the decision that he was “fit for work” had been the trigger for his suicide.

Campaigners believe the decision led to other deaths

Smith and Grayling assumed responsibility for responding to a letter written by coroner Tom Osborne, who carried out the inquest into Carré’s death, in which he outlined serious concerns about the safety of the WCA.

Osborne asked to review the WCA policy in light of people who had problems with mental illness.

Campaigners, including Black Triangle, believe that the decision of Duncan Smith and Grayling to ignore Osborne’s letter led to other deaths.

The Department of Work and Pensions had been contacted for comment.

 

Comments

0 0
Tony Dean
over 8 years ago
I suggest David Woolfenden so that you don't put both feet in your mouth again that you do some research on a subject before commenting about it. The number of deaths caused by very ill people being found wrongly fit for work is a national disgrace as are the number of suicides directly related to benefit sanctions of mentally ill and mentally handicapped people.
0 0
Calum McLean
over 8 years ago
There have actually been over 4,000 cases where the Duncan-Smith's DWP have declare sick people fit-for-work and they have died within a year of the ConDem government dumping them: https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/mortality-statistics-esa-ib-and-sda-claimants . Just Google "welfare reform deaths" for more information. One of 60 criminal cases going to Police Scotland and, or the Met Police, plus regional police forces: Stephanie Bottrill. On 4th May 2013 Stephanie left an explicit and unequivocal note blaming the ConDem government's welfare cuts; and then she committed suicide because of the DWP. Over a year earlier, Iain Duncan Smith and Chris Grayling were WARNED in the Palace of Westminster that THEIR welfare reforms were LETHAL and they were NOT immune from prosecution. Proof: http://archive.is/TVQjl#selection-4601.0-4629.334 - This may take some time, but just like the Hillsborough 96 families, justice WILL be served.
0 0
david woolfenden
over 8 years ago
Why would genuine sick people fear testing, there are too many slackers and hangers on not willing to work who have imaginary illnesses in order to laze around doing nothing whilst good, honest, hard working people keep putting buns in their lazy good for nothing mouths. They should be ashamed of themselves. I'm fed up hearing about these do-gooders protecting workshy individuals and abusing our institutions meant to safeguard the vunerable in order to protect these punks. About time they were hounded out of town!
0 0
Calum McLean
over 8 years ago
David Woolfenden, You are either an arch-Tory with Dickensian workhouse and poor-law views, or someone who better hope you never get ill. You can become disabled with a life changing illness diagnosed overnight. God forbid it happens to you David. I was very fit and healthy - serving as a police officer for years. Then became injured whilst saving someone from drowning. Lifting a waterlogged and unconscious person out of the sea gave me the the first problem with a bad back. Then extracting someone choking to death from a trapped position burst one of the discs in my back. That resulted in spinal surgery. With the help of pain meds I have WORKED all of my life. I resent disability-haters like Woolfenden calling me a scrounger. Especially as when I sold my home, I sent the DLA book back and saved the taxpayer £40,000 to date. Whereas millionaire David Cameron scrounged DLA for his family. Worse, I've known three hard working people who have become disabled, and then subject to the corrupt and gerrymandered WCA disability assessment scheme run by Mr Woolfenden's friends. One dropped dead of a heart attack literally hours after having the fourth bent Tory WCA tests in 15 months - an assessment that has left him without any support for his 30 years of NI payments into the system. The other two have gone from decent long-term jobs to near destitution. David, you say you want disabled people hounded out of town when in fact they are being hounded to their deaths. Fortunately nobody of consequence will listen to your disgraceful words any more. The jig is up. There is FAR TOO MUCH evidence collated to pursue Duncan Smith and his cronies. It will be up to HM Courts to reach a verdict on the 4,000 deaths of disabled people shortly after Tory WCA assessments say they are fit-to-work. David Woolfenden and his ilk clearly hate the disabled and the time for their opinions to be taken seriously has now, thankfully past.
Commenting is now closed on this post